CBS has launched 44 seasons of Survivor since 2000, and with that many iterations of the truth competitors collection, some are certain to be flops. The producers are consistently making an attempt new issues, resulting in huge success (re: hidden immunity idols), and others have been full hits and misses (re: Fringe of Extinction). However unhealthy twists and themes aren’t the one contributors to the factors of the present’s worst seasons; generally, a solid can result in a season’s downfall. Learn on for our 5 least favourite Survivor competitions.
5. ‘Survivor 43’ was probably the most disappointing seasons
Survivor 43 had the potential to be among the finest seasons of the “new era.” Sadly, poor enhancing, unclear storytelling, a heartbreaking exit attributable to a irritating fire-making twist, and a baffling winner made it one of many worst seasons ever.
In fact, recency bias has performed a giant half in our views on Survivor 43. However trying again on the season as an entire, we simply really feel huge waves of disappointment. It contained a terrific solid with passionate gamers (together with one we regard as among the finest castaways within the present’s historical past). Nevertheless, as an alternative of highlighting camp dynamics and strategic plans, episodes had been filled with challenges and backstories.
Whereas Survivor 43 ought to be remembered for Jesse Lopez’s spectacular blindside of his closest ally, we are able to’t get the poor style of Mike Gabler profitable over Cassidy Clark out of our mouths. And for that motive, amongst many others, Survivor 43 is on our worst seasons listing.
4. ‘Survivor: Nicaragua’
Survivor winners play a big position in how we understand the seasons. And sadly for Nicaragua, its Sole Survivor was a serious letdown attributable to his lack of strategic gameplay. However Jud “Fabio” Birza’s win wasn’t the one factor flawed with season 21 — the tribe divisions and a twist referred to as the “Medallion of Power” had been additionally duds.
Survivor producers divided the tribes by age — Espada contained castaways who had been 40 years previous or older, and La Flor featured contestants youthful than 30. And the 2 tribes consistently vied for possession of the Medallion, which might give them a bonus at challenges.
Sadly for producers, each of those twists flopped exhausting. The Medallion of Energy was by no means seen once more following Survivor: Nicaragua. And the one different season to characteristic an age division was the far superior Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X. So, similar to producers, we might very very like to depart season 21 up to now.
3. ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’
Survivor Season 38 featured a twist referred to as the Fringe of Extinction, which was mainly a tweaked model of Redemption Island. Voted-out gamers would dwell on a separate island till they might compete for an opportunity to reenter the sport. However they might “raise the sail” anytime and forfeit their shot to return.
Though the Fringe of Extinction saved one of the best participant in season 38 — Rick Devens (who’s on our listing of Survivor castaways who have to return in an All-Stars season) — it additionally produced probably the most underwhelming winners within the present’s historical past.
Chris Underwood spent nearly all of his time on the Fringe of Extinction. So he solely received as a result of he created bonds with the jury whereas on the Edge and beat Rick in fireplace. And don’t get us began on how Chris started a pattern the place the ultimate 4 Immunity Problem winner is just deemed worthy of turning into the Sole Survivor if they provide up immunity to make fireplace and take out the season’s greatest participant.
Survivor: Fringe of Extinction taught us two issues; producers have to abolish the ultimate 4 fire-making problem ASAP, and as soon as castaways are voted out, they shouldn’t have the ability to return.
2. ‘Survivor: Island of the Idols’
The most unforgettable second of Survivor: Island of the Idols was when Kellee Kim and different feminine castaways accused Dan Spilo of sexual assault. And that issue alone just about sums up why it’s close to the highest of our worst Survivor seasons listing.
The state of affairs surrounding Dan in some way acquired even worse when Missy Byrd and Elizabeth Beisel lied and stated that Dan made them uncomfortable, too. They agreed to aspect with Kellee and Janet Carbin to vote him out on the merge. However Missy and Elizabeth modified their minds and joined the bulk in writing Kellee’s identify down.
On Day 36, manufacturing lastly eliminated Dan from the sport following an off-camera incident that didn’t contain a participant. A number of viewers expressed concern with how lengthy it took CBS to take care of Dan’s conduct, and his presence undoubtedly tainted the season. And the state of affairs pressured Survivor producers to rethink their protocols for future seasons.
Survivor: Island of the Idols has a darkish cloud hanging over it. And we’re glad that it impressed change, however we might even be completely satisfied by no means to consider it once more.
1. ‘Survivor: Thailand’ is the worst out of all the seasons
Survivor: Thailand is the proper instance of how a solid can break a season. Just like Island of the Idols, season 5 contained sexual assault allegations. However not like season 39, producers and castaways brushed it beneath the rug. In actual fact, the sufferer of the assault was handled like rubbish, and all of the blame was shifted onto her.
On Day 7, Ghandia Johnson accused Ted Rogers, Jr. of assaulting her the evening earlier than. Ted apologized, however when phrase acquired out to their tribe members, he fervently denied that something had occurred. The males of the tribe sided with Ted, whereas the ladies sided with Ghandia. Sadly, Helen Glover didn’t need to go to rocks, so she joined the lads in voting out Ghandia at their subsequent Tribal Council.
Except for the sexual assault allegations, season 5 was mind-numbing to observe attributable to its irritating solid, complicated faux merge, and unlikable winner.
Survivor: Thailand is a darkish nook of the CBS actuality present’s historical past, making it the worst season of all time.
For extra on the leisure world and unique interviews, subscribe to Showbiz Cheat Sheet’s YouTube channel.
get assist: For those who or somebody you realize has been sexually abused, textual content HOME to the Disaster Textual content Line at 741741 at no cost and confidential help.